one streetback

Edinburgh · 11 November 2026

Visiting Edinburgh? Eat in Marchmont, not on the Royal Mile

By our measure 4 of the 15 neighbourhoods within 15 minutes of Edinburgh's centre have more places for visitors than everyday shops. The Old Town has 139 to 97. Marchmont, 2 km south, still has 69 everyday shops to 16, and Pilrig, on Leith Walk, has 99 to 39.

Edinburgh: "Going to Edinburgh? Eat in Marchmont or Pilrig, not on the Royal Mile." over a photo of a café front on Argyle Place, Marchmont, on a wet day, looking towards the Meadows.

Going to Edinburgh? Go and see the castle. Then walk south across the Meadows and have your dinner in Marchmont, or head down Leith Walk to Pilrig. Sleep in a hotel, a guesthouse or a holiday let with a council licence. Every holiday let in Scotland is meant to have one.

Fodor's has put Edinburgh on its No List for 2027, its yearly list of places it thinks travellers should think twice about. Forbes reported it on 10 November. The list points to the Royal Mile, where the BBC counted 72 gift shops last year, and to the crowds that come for the Fringe. We think Fodor's has picked the wrong target. Edinburgh isn't full. A few streets in the middle are, and telling people to stay away from a whole city just sends the crowd somewhere else.

We count shops. In each neighbourhood near the centre we compare everyday shops with places aimed at visitors, like hotels and souvenir shops, using OpenStreetMap. By our measure 4 of the 15 have tipped. The Old Town, around the Royal Mile, has 139 places for visitors to 97 everyday shops. Canongate, further down towards Holyrood, has 98 to 52. New Town and Broughton are only just over the line. Inside Airbnb counts 834 whole homes listed within a ten-minute walk of the Old Town.

Marchmont, 2 km south, still goes the other way: 69 everyday shops to 16 for visitors, and 177 homes on Airbnb around it, about a fifth of the Old Town's figure. Pilrig, 1.4 km out on the way down Leith Walk, passes too: 99 everyday shops to 39 for visitors. Siamack walked it the other day: lovely shops and restaurants, nearly all of them for people who live there. It has more homes on Airbnb around it than Marchmont, 458. Eat in either and walk round. If every visitor moved in too, they'd tip as well, so keep your bed in a licensed place.

Original reporting: Where Tourists Should Rethink 2027 Travel Plans Because Of Overtourism, Forbes

Data: OpenStreetMap contributors · Inside Airbnb, CC BY 4.0 · Photo: Richard Webb, CC BY-SA 2.0, Wikimedia Commons

See Edinburgh on One Street Back

All stories